Elektrine lite

← Feed

@josch@floss.social

2026-10-26 14:02 UTC

For now, I will no longer be uploading to the #Debian NEW queue. And yes, I will now go outside and do something nice instead of trying to argue on mailing lists about #LLM use in #FOSS. Maybe do the same. The weather is great outside. :) https://lists.debian.org/debian-devel/2026/10/msg00263.html

Replies (24)

  • @soapdog@social.soapdog.org 2026-10-26 14:15

    @josch@floss.social I am so sorry Debian is going this route and that you found yourself in such position. That sucks. Hope your time outside is great (it is raining a lot here so it is time for coding with rain sounds for me)

    Open ##5449937

  • @bremner@mathstodon.xyz 2026-10-26 14:29

    @josch@floss.social Thanks, you hit all the points I wanted to mention.

    Open ##5449943

  • @malte@anticapitalist.party 2026-10-26 15:00

    @josch@floss.social :anarchoheart2:

    Open ##5449945

  • @rick@a.n0id.space 2026-10-26 15:11

    @josch@floss.social urgh i hate this tl... sending virtual hugs

    Open ##5449946

  • @alxndr@tech.lgbt 2026-10-26 15:40

    @josch@floss.social The "C" in AI is for consent. /s #Debian #NoAI

    Open ##5449949

  • @giacomo@snac.tesio.it 2026-10-26 16:57

    @josch@floss.social I'm afraid the capture of #Debian will pass through similar insulting behaviours (such pushing LLM output on people who refuse it) that will alienate all politically aware developers. It's sad, but likely the goal of those who made this move. Maybe you might find some joy working on #NetBSD or even on #9front. Good luck! And thanks for fighting this fight.

    Open ##5449953

  • @mildpeach@mstdn.social 2026-10-26 17:40

    @josch@floss.social @Lamuchan@eldritch.cafe As a debian user this is quite disturbing.

    Open ##5449956

  • @josch@floss.social this mirrors how I feel about contributing to the Linux kernel now. It's become even more hell than it was before.

    Open ##5449963

  • @TFF@defcon.social 2026-10-26 18:38

    @josch@floss.social It is indeed nice outside. 73° isn't what I'd call "Fall weather", especially for October, but any chance I have to just sit and enjoy the sun it is appreciated.

    Open ##5449964

  • @josch@floss.social amen. Touching grass is the best thing we can do, us, careful people.

    Open ##5449975

  • @leony@sunny.garden 2026-10-26 21:36

    @josch@floss.social I am very sorry for you. I am sorry that AI is destroying your hobby, destroying so many beautiful things in the world: Art, poetry, things that are fun, creativity, water, nature, energy... All for a capitalistic world... I wish you a lot of strength, a lot of good friends and some positive attitude or whatever you need right now :)

    Open ##5449978

  • @josch@floss.social i'm unable to read it. what happened?

    Open ##5449979

  • @brettm@swarm.coiloptic.org 2026-10-26 23:39

    @josch@floss.social good choice! fwiw i stopped trusting debian long ago when they went with systemd 🙂

    Open ##5449983

  • @bignose@fosstodon.org 2026-10-26 23:42

    Thank you @josch@floss.social for a well-written thread starter. I am glad it surfaced significant #Debian member resistance to this imposition of #AISlop on our (often volunteer) work. Also glad that there is a “work item” [0] for the team that began this, to change it so we don't have #LLMs imposed on our work. [0]: not linking to the work item because it's an internal discussion that should not be dogpiled. Just surfacing the fact so people know there's ongoing resistance and hope for improvement.

    Open ##5449985

  • @CountHoldem@mastodon.social 2026-10-27 01:39

    @josch@floss.social I'm in full support of LLM's protecting root infrastructure from 'rogue' AI, as well as redirecting obese Capitalism greed, to the most needy. - De Oppresso Liber

    Open ##5449988

  • @etbe@mastodon.nzoss.nz 2026-10-27 05:01

    @josch@floss.social I agree this is not being done in the right way. I don't object to it as strongly as you do and I will keep doing Debian work as normal. But I think it should have been implemented in a different way and had more input into the process. An optional tool that developers can run before upload would be a better option. That would save the time of the DFSG team who have responded to some silly mistakes I've made...

    Open ##5449990

  • @fbinin@mastodon.fbin.in 2026-10-27 07:20

    @fdroidorg@floss.social Ermmmm see this and a lot of others maybe out there being fed through..

    Open ##5449999

  • @buhtz@fosstodon.org 2026-10-27 07:52

    @josch@floss.social As upstream maintainer always having an eye on #Debian packaging I support your step and #thankYou for opening this discussion on #Debian.

    Open ##5450000

  • @dzu@hostsharing.coop 2026-10-27 11:44

    @josch@floss.social Thanks for bringing this topic to a wider audience and also thank you for linking to your long description of the issue at hand. 👏 From reading that text, I also get the idea that this is an overstepping on what was promised. Hopefully this can be resolved without scaring away too many people.

    Open ##5450005

  • @invisible@hachyderm.io 2026-10-27 13:05

    @josch@floss.social Thank you for your work on #Debian and for showing others what being true to your principles looks like.

    Open ##5450011

  • @gekitsu@toot.cat 2026-10-27 18:22

    @josch@floss.social i appreciate your good and principled stance! (and, since i saw you mention WÜ in the replies: servus und gruesse ein paar km den main hoch!)

    Open ##5450014

  • @josch@floss.social thank you very much for the work youve done, im sorry this happened and i wish you the best -end user

    Open ##5450015

  • @josch@floss.social I started my first #computer in 1983, thanks to my family it was a clone of an #appleII which was then banned out of the market . Then in 2000 the next big move (after #OS and several #windows on floppies) was #Mandrake, #Suse , #debian and finally #ubuntu as I got old and lazier. What is my alternative now...

    Open ##5450017

  • @mjlmo@social.vivaldi.net 2026-10-27 20:07

    @josch@floss.social Man, this is really an issue. It's the future #AISlop dystopia on #foss 🤔

    Open ##5450018