Elektrine lite

← Feed

@Fishd@infosec.exchange

2026-07-31 08:06 UTC

@Joobidube@mastodon.social @ChrisMayLA6@mastodon.me.uk Going to be a Danny Downer here but can anyone point to a time when a 38degrees petition actually came to anything? I appreciate that they have a page of "successful campaigns" but a lot of them appear to be claiming victory when it appears the other side just changed their mind and decided to do something else instead. (I really doubt a campaign with 174 signatures led to meaningful change). I think the government is well aware that the ease of signing an online petition makes it worthless. Even the parliamentary ones. There is a way to show government how much you care about a cause and that is physical protest. The Suffragettes, the Kinder Tresspass, the Miners Strikes, and so on. 38degrees seems like a great idea but honestly, at this point it feels like it's part of the problem. Complete a few petitions and they have built a database of U.K. citizens with a set of grievances... I can imagine it being relatively easy for the police to get a court order to seize that database and you've just done their job for them.

Replies (1)

  • @ChrisMayLA6@mastodon.me.uk 2026-07-31 09:19

    @Fishd@infosec.exchange @Joobidube@mastodon.social Despite having signed the petition posted this morning, I share much of the scepticism about their impact - it was a point I used to make to students; the easier the protest is todo from your chair, the less likely anyone will take any notice... and as you rightly say that does play out into direct action. However, what is interesting for such direct actors is the gauge of potentially friendly support that may be floating round. The surveillance state angle is interesting!

    Open ##4279432