2026-09-11 17:24 UTC
Replies (4)
-
@IlovePizza@lemmy.world 2026-09-11 18:06
Let’s remove art from the debate then. It’s something that presumably took hard work and now that hard work is put into question.
-
@HerbGrower@slrpnk.net 2026-09-11 17:56
And how is an AI system going to identify that or not? Also I don’t really like that definition for art. Feels kinda pretentious/gatekeeping. But inevitably that does lead us to what even is art.
-
@OneCardboardBox@lemmy.sdf.org 2026-09-11 18:13
I’m not going to say that all things created by people aren’t slop, but it’s also true that our context for understanding art can change over time. What we’re getting now, with certain art styles being associated with slop is a kind of Seinfeld effect. To give a specific example: When the movie Annihilation came out, it quickly became a favorite of mine. I loved its visual style, and the narrative theme about broken people. A few months ago I re-watched it and realized that its visuals have been so coopted by endless slop recreations that I couldn’t disassociate it from AI output. Even though the themes were still there and no less resonant than when I first watched it, my brain couldn’t enjoy the film because I kept thinking about slop. The movie hadn’t changed and all the artistic intentionality behind its creation was still there, but my ability to enjoy it was destroyed.
-
@petrol_sniff_king@lemmy.blahaj.zone 2026-09-11 20:52
If an image can’t be distinguished from what AI produces, isn’t it obviously slop too and not art either? I can’t distinguish AlteredEgo’s comment from AI, so I think it may just be slop by default. Yeah. Unfortunately, he has nothing interesting to say—I’ve literally heard these exact words from like a hundred other places, so… I guess he’s just not worth talking to. What a boring guy. Really an NPC, if I’ve ever seen one. Try to be more original, Ego. Originality, yeah. Then I think you might be worth listening to.